The Thurgood Marshall U.S. Courthouse on Foley Square, Manhattan — home of the Southern District of New York, which declined to charge Leon Black despite three years of accumulating evidence.
The Billion-Dollar Blind Eye
Three victims. Forensic journals. Bank records. A $62.5 million settlement. A $158 million relationship with Epstein. And an AUSA who admitted: "I did not write anything up on Leon Black."
On May 18, 2021, an assistant United States attorney in the Southern District of New York interviewed a woman who said Leon Black had violently raped her for nearly a decade.1
The FBI had already forwarded its 302 reports. The victim's attorney, Jeanne Christensen of Wigdor LLP, had sent bank statements showing wire transfers from "Leon J. Black," "J. Black Trust," and "E Trust" — payments ranging from $15,000 to $167,000.2 The victim had sent Black a text message: "Leon. You sexually harassed me, sex trafficked me, raped me, and eventually blacklisted me."3
Ten days later, the AUSA wrote to a colleague:
"I'm not inclined to open based on the other victim, for a variety of reasons."4
The case was never formally opened. It was never formally closed. It simply ceased to exist — until the documents were released to the public five years later.
The Ten-Day Dismissal
The speed of the dismissal is itself evidence. On April 22, 2021, Christensen first contacted the AUSA about Black.5 By April 29, the FBI agent was ready: "Once you're ready to set up an interview, let me know."6 On May 18, the interview took place at 290 Broadway.1 On May 27, the bank statements arrived.2
On May 28 — one day after receiving financial proof of payments from a billionaire to a trafficking victim — the case was dismissed without a formal write-up.4
The Second Victim
Three months after the dismissal, the case should have been reopened.
On August 9, 2021, Christensen called with news of a second victim — a woman who had come forward completely independently. Her account of Black's violence was identical to the first: the same signature ritual, the same escalation pattern. Christensen told prosecutors:
"The details she told me about what he did to her — are almost a perfect match... he violently bit down on her vulva, labia and clitoris. The biting would get harder and his teeth clamp down more when she yelled out in pain... it is too abnormal to make up."8
The second victim had met Black at Jeffrey Epstein's Manhattan townhouse while giving massages. Black called her afterward and gave her $5,000 in cash. She had no contact with the first victim. There was nothing publicly available about the specific details of Black's conduct. Two independent women described the same act.8
The AUSA's response, in an internal email:
"I'd like to do that so it doesn't seem like we are just rebuffing the victim."9
The interview was delayed until after the Ghislaine Maxwell trial. The concern was not justice. It was optics.
The Billion-Dollar Man
Leon Black is the founder of Apollo Global Management, one of the world's largest private equity firms. His net worth is approximately $10 billion. Between 2012 and 2017, he paid Jeffrey Epstein $158 million for what was described as "tax and estate planning services."10
The U.S. Senate Finance Committee investigated these payments in July 2023. Their findings were damning:10
- No written services agreement or contract existed
- Payments "far exceeded any amounts Black paid to his other professional advisors" — including "some of the most high-priced legal counsel in the nation"
- Epstein was not a CPA or licensed tax attorney
- Black was "under the misconception" that payments were tax-deductible because "this is what Epstein had told Black"
- Black refused to answer Senate questions about how payments were calculated
The payments purchased a specific service. Epstein devised a trust scheme using 2006 GRATs funded with Apollo partnership interests — appraised at roughly $585 million but expected to exceed $2 billion. The scheme kept those assets outside Black's taxable estate. Estimated tax savings: over $1 billion.10
The IRS has never audited these transactions.
The Minor Victim
By 2023, the Manhattan District Attorney's office had developed what SDNY would not.
On February 28, 2023, DANY reported "a new CW who has come forward and alleged sexual abuse by Leon Black. This CW was trafficked by Maxwell and Epstein."11 On May 26, Christensen provided the details: Black had assaulted a sixteen-year-old girl trafficked from Virginia to Epstein's New York townhouse.12
The DANY memo documented what happened to her:
"Black used adult sex toys in victim's rectum and vagina. Victim felt severe pinching in her vagina and began bleeding from her rectum; Black and others at Epstein's house would not take her to the doctor and instead flew her out of NY the next day."12
Epstein and Black referred to the child as "being 10."12 From 2001 to 2004, she was "trafficked by [a female recruiter], sex with at least 25 different men."12 Medical records from 2011 and 2019 documented ongoing injuries from the assaults.13
When this testimony reached SDNY on May 30, 2023, the original AUSA's response was the admission that would define the case: "I did not write anything up on Leon Black."7
A supervisor concurred: "[The AUSA] looked at it but determined it was not viable for our office to pursue (and I agreed with her assessment)."14
The Formal Decline
On July 21, 2023, Christensen made one more attempt:
"Leon Black paid 62.5 million to USVI... one lawyer represents ten women that he sexually assaulted... it's outrageous that criminal charges have not been brought against him."15
The next day, the Civil Rights Unit issued its formal decline: "There does not appear to be any evidence of overlap with Maxwell... CRU doesn't intend to open anything separate based on current information."16
This rationale — "no overlap with Maxwell" — was contradicted by the DANY testimony sitting in their own files. The minor victim had been "trafficked by Maxwell and Epstein."11 Maxwell had introduced her to the operation.12 The CRU's stated basis for declining was factually wrong.
On August 2, 2023, SDNY made it official: "Agree with DTC" — Decline to Charge.17
The Journals
The evidence continued to arrive even after the decline.
On March 15, 2024, a victim testified before Judge Jed Rakoff in SDNY. The court ordered a forensic examination of her handwritten journals — four years of entries, written in code while she was being trafficked, naming more than 30 abusers.18
The results came back in April-May 2024: gel pen throughout, no evidence of recent fabrication. The journals were authentic.18
Wigdor briefed SDNY on the authentication results on May 30, 2024. The response: silence.18
On July 9, 2024, Christensen marked her request as "urgent."19 The last known SDNY communication was an apology: "Sorry, I have been on trial."20
On January 30, 2026, Dataset 12 was released to the public. The documents that prosecutors had declined to act on became the documents that anyone could read.
Zero charges have been filed.
The Two-Track Failure
Leon Black paid $158 million to a sex trafficker. He paid $62.5 million to the U.S. Virgin Islands. He forced a victim to sign an NDA under duress and then denied her a copy of it.3 He contacted a victim after learning she had given statements to prosecutors.21 He hired Brad Edwards — a prominent victims' rights attorney — creating a conflict of interest that potentially neutralized legal opposition.22
The victim wrote to him: "Unfortunately I am still tied to you."3
The Southern District of New York did not write anything up.
Get help building custom platforms, AI-powered tools, and data-driven applications for your business or projects.
This article is based on documents released under the Epstein Files Transparency Act (EFTA). All claims are sourced to specific EFTA documents identified by Bates number. Entity tier classifications reflect evidence strength, not legal determinations.
Research and initial drafting assisted by Claude AI (Anthropic). All articles are reviewed, fact-checked, and edited by Derek Emsbach.
Continue Reading
Related investigations
The Case That Wasn’t
The prosecution memo documented 38 victims and multiple perpetrators. The Leon Black investigation accumulated three years of evidence. In both cases, the institutional answer was the same: decline.
The Trustee With No Exit
Jes Staley signed the Epstein trust three times, retained Epstein as a banking client after his conviction, and was documented by prosecutors as having raped a victim during a directed massage. No resignation from the trust has been found. No charges have been filed.
The System
Five interlocking components — financial incentives, governance control, witness suppression, beneficiary alignment, and prosecutorial inaction — produced one outcome: the evidence is in the public record, the accountability is not.
Curious what Epstein and his network talked about?
A community-built email archive spanning years of private correspondence within the Epstein network.
Explore the Archive →